Your answer is also incorrect.
One doesn't need to perform this experiment to know the answers to these relatively simple questions, if one truly understands the dynamics involved. What has become clear is that neither you nor Harvey have a good understanding of the dynamics involved in this experiment. It's therefore ironic that you both believe I am wrong about the statements I've made thus far. I encourage both of you to perform this experiment and make the measurements I have outlined here. Prove it to yourself.
exnihiloest has the correct values, but the experiment is not nearly as sensitive to error as he has alluded to.
The correct answer to the most recent question regarding the RIGHT side of the experiment, is:
CH1 = 0.9V CH2 = 0.9V
Of course when we move the probes to the LEFT side, the answer will be:
CH1 = -0.1V CH2 = -0.1V
Not while using galvanometers. Yes, I now wish more than ever to perform the experiment. Agreed, sarcasm is problematic on text based forums. I'll quote and comment rather than repeat and hope folks get it. Ex is wrong simply because there is no reversal of magnetic polarity on a setup identical to the Lewin experiment anywhere outside the coil except above and below the coil. Harvey is correct about impedance being an important consideration. Apparently, the dynamics aren't as simple as stated. With that said, Yes, I will start assembling the experiment and report back here as soon as possible.
|